Fool Me Four Times...

You may only cast Fool me Four Times if there are three or more cards of the same name in an opponent's graveyard.
Counter each noncreature spell that shares a name with a card in an opponent's graveyard.
"For a guy who can hear people's thoughts, Jace was a pretty easy person to prank. I guess he finally got tired of it." - Chandra, to Nahiri