How You Like That

When another player casts a spell, you may
pay {2} and deal 1 point of damage to them. If
that spell was cast during your turn, you may
also pay 1 life and give target creature you control First Strike until your next upkeep.
If that spell was cast during your combat phase
you may also sacrifice a counter and give a permanent you control Indestructible until
your next upkeep.